“Good to Great” by Jim Collins is a groundbreaking business book that explores how companies transform from being good companies to truly great ones. Based on extensive research spanning five years, Collins and his team studied companies that made the leap from good performance to great performance and sustained it for at least fifteen years. The book presents evidence-based insights into the key factors that enable this transformation.

The research identified several key principles that differentiate companies that made the leap to greatness from comparison companies that failed to do so. These principles challenge many traditional notions about corporate success and leadership, offering a framework that focuses on disciplined people, disciplined thought, and disciplined action.

0:00 / 0:00

Key Concepts

Level 5 Leadership

One of the most surprising findings in Collins’ research was the type of leadership that characterized good-to-great companies. He introduces the concept of Level 5 Leadership, which describes executives who combine extreme personal humility with intense professional will.

Level 5 leaders are characterized by:

  • Paradoxical blend of personal humility and professional will
  • Ambition for the company’s success rather than personal glory
  • Setting up successors for even greater success
  • Taking responsibility for poor results while attributing success to others

These leaders work diligently to build sustainable organizations rather than seeking quick fixes or personal acclaim. They focus on long-term results and building lasting greatness rather than short-term gains.

A prime example is Darwin Smith of Kimberly-Clark, who despite his shy demeanor and initial self-doubt, transformed the company from a struggling paper mill into a consumer goods powerhouse, outperforming the market by 4.1 times over his tenure.

First Who, Then What

Collins found that great companies focus first on getting the right people on board (and the wrong people off) before determining strategy or vision. This principle emphasizes:

  • The importance of rigorous personnel decisions
  • Putting the best people in positions of greatest opportunity
  • Being selective in hiring even during periods of growth
  • Making personnel changes decisively when needed

The research showed that great companies focused on building exceptional teams before defining their strategic direction. This approach provided maximum flexibility to adapt to changing conditions while maintaining organizational strength.

Circuit City exemplified this principle by taking an average of 6 months to fill key positions, demonstrating extraordinary patience in their pursuit of the right people. This careful selection process contributed to their cumulative stock returns of 18.5 times the market in the fifteen years after their transformation.

Confront the Brutal Facts

Great companies maintain unwavering faith in their ability to prevail while simultaneously confronting the brutal facts of their current reality. This concept involves:

  • Creating a climate where truth is heard
  • Leading with questions, not answers
  • Engaging in dialogue and debate, not coercion
  • Conducting autopsies without blame
  • Building red flag mechanisms to turn information into insight

This disciplined approach to reality-based decision making helps organizations maintain clarity about their challenges while preserving confidence in their ultimate success.

A striking example is how Philip Morris confronted the brutal reality of the growing anti-smoking movement in the 1950s, rather than denying it. The company diversified into other industries while maintaining its core business, leading to returns 7.3 times the market average over the study period.

The Hedgehog Concept

Named after Isaiah Berlin’s essay comparing the hedgehog’s simple, focused strategy to the fox’s complex one, this concept represents the intersection of three circles:

  • What you can be the best in the world at
  • What drives your economic engine
  • What you are deeply passionate about

Great companies focus relentlessly on their hedgehog concept, saying no to opportunities that don’t fit within these three circles. This disciplined approach helps organizations maintain focus and avoid the scattering of resources across too many initiatives.

Walgreens demonstrated this principle by focusing exclusively on convenient drugstores, even selling its profitable food service business. This focus led to returns 7.3 times the general market over fifteen years as they became the best, most convenient drugstore chain in America.

Culture of Discipline

Great organizations combine an ethic of entrepreneurship with disciplined thought and action. This culture is characterized by:

  • Freedom within a framework of responsibilities
  • Disciplined people who engage in disciplined thought
  • Disciplined action aligned with the hedgehog concept
  • Consistent adherence to carefully chosen systems and standards

This discipline enables organizations to achieve sustainable results without relying on bureaucracy or excessive controls.

Abbott Laboratories exemplified this principle by maintaining a strict adherence to their standards even during the Great Depression, continuing to invest in R&D while others cut back. This disciplined approach helped them achieve returns 4.5 times the market average during the study period.

Technology Accelerators

While technology plays a role in great companies, it is never the primary driver of success. Great companies:

  • Use technology as an accelerator of momentum, not a creator of it
  • Carefully select technologies that fit their hedgehog concept
  • Avoid jumping on technology bandwagons
  • Become pioneers in the application of carefully selected technologies

This measured approach to technology ensures that technological investments support rather than drive the organization’s strategy.

Kroger demonstrated this principle by being an early adopter of barcode scanning technology, but only after determining it would support their consumer-first strategy. This disciplined approach to technology contributed to their cumulative returns of 12 times the market over the study period.

Conclusion

“Good to Great” provides a research-based framework for understanding organizational transformation. The book’s key findings challenge conventional wisdom about corporate success and offer practical insights for leaders seeking to build truly great organizations.

The enduring value of Collins’ work lies in its empirical approach and actionable insights. The principles identified remain relevant across different industries and time periods, offering a roadmap for organizational excellence that focuses on disciplined people, thought, and action.

In today’s rapidly changing business environment, the book’s emphasis on foundational principles rather than quick fixes or trendy solutions is particularly valuable. Organizations that apply these principles thoughtfully can build lasting success rather than achieving merely temporary advantages.

The impact of “Good to Great” extends beyond business to any organization seeking to achieve and sustain superior performance. Its insights about leadership, people, strategy, and execution provide a framework for transformation that can be adapted to various organizational contexts.

While we strive to provide comprehensive summaries, they cannot capture every nuance and insight from the full book. For the complete experience and to support the author's work, we encourage you to read the full book.

If you enjoyed “Good to Great” by Jim Collins, you might also find these books valuable:

  1. “Built to Last” by Jim Collins and Jerry Porras

    • Another seminal work by Collins that examines what makes enduringly great companies different from others, focusing on visionary companies that have prospered over decades.

  2. “Great by Choice” by Jim Collins and Morten Hansen

    • A follow-up study examining how companies can thrive in chaos and uncertainty, providing insights into what makes some companies perform exceptionally well in unstable environments.

  3. “The Innovator’s Dilemma” by Clayton Christensen

    • This influential book explores why great companies can fail precisely because they do everything right, offering crucial insights about disruptive innovation and organizational adaptation.

  4. “Blue Ocean Strategy” by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne

    • Complements “Good to Great” by providing a framework for creating uncontested market space and making competition irrelevant through strategic moves that create “blue oceans” of opportunity.